Signs Your Car’s Thermostat Is Stuck Open or Closed

May 30, 2025

If your engine’s running unusually cold or heating up too quickly, your thermostat might be stuck. This small cooling system component has a big impact on how your car warms up and maintains the right operating temperature. When it fails in either the stuck open or closed position, you’ll likely notice poor fuel efficiency, rough performance, or even signs of overheating.


We’ll cover the most common symptoms of a thermostat that isn’t working properly and why catching the problem early can save you from engine trouble later on.


How the Thermostat Works


The thermostat sits between your engine and the radiator. Its job is to open and close depending on the engine temperature. When the engine is cold, the thermostat stays closed to help it warm up faster. Once it reaches the ideal temperature, the thermostat opens to let coolant flow to the radiator, where excess heat is released.


If it gets stuck open, your engine may never warm up properly. If it gets stuck closed, the coolant won’t circulate, causing the engine to overheat. Both situations can lead to performance problems and long-term wear if not addressed.


Signs the Thermostat Is Stuck Open


When a thermostat is stuck in the open position, coolant constantly flows through the radiator, even when the engine is cold. This prevents the engine from reaching its proper operating temperature, especially in cooler climates.


Common signs include:


  • The temperature gauge stays unusually low after several minutes of driving
  • Heater blows lukewarm or cold air, even when fully turned on
  • Reduced fuel efficiency, as the engine works harder to maintain performance
  • Increased emissions due to improper engine temperature


This issue can be more noticeable in winter months around Toms River. Your cabin may stay chilly longer, and the vehicle may take longer to respond smoothly.


Signs the Thermostat Is Stuck Closed


A closed thermostat traps coolant inside the engine, preventing it from cooling down. This can lead to rapid overheating, which is one of the most dangerous issues your car can face.


Symptoms include:


  • The temperature gauge climbs quickly into the red zone
  • You see steam or smoke coming from under the hood
  • A warning light or overheating message appears on the dashboard
  • Strange smells, often sweet or burning, are coming from the engine bay


If you notice these signs, pull over and shut off the engine immediately. Driving with an overheating engine can warp the cylinder head or cause head gasket failure—repairs that cost far more than replacing a thermostat.


Thermostat Problems Often Go Unnoticed Until It’s Too Late


Because a thermostat issue may not cause obvious symptoms at first, many drivers don’t notice anything until performance suffers or the engine overheats. That’s why routine cooling system checks are important, especially on vehicles over 8–10 years old or those with high mileage.


Thermostats are relatively inexpensive to replace but play a critical role in keeping your engine safe. If your heater isn’t working well, or the temperature gauge seems off, it’s worth having the thermostat checked as part of a larger cooling system inspection.


What to Expect From a Thermostat Replacement


  • Removing and replacing the thermostat with a new, OEM-quality part
  • Draining and refilling the coolant if necessary
  • Bleeding air from the cooling system to ensure proper circulation
  • Verifying that the new thermostat opens and closes at the right temperature


At PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair, we make sure the entire cooling system is checked during the process. A thermostat issue is often linked with other problems like a clogged radiator, bad hoses, or a failing water pump.


PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair – Cooling System Specialists in Toms River, NJ


At PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair in Toms River, we will help you stay ahead of thermostat trouble and cooling system failures. Whether your engine is overheating or your heater’s gone cold, we’ll get to the root of the issue and restore proper temperature control.


Schedule a visit today and let our team keep your car running comfortably in every season.

What to Do When My Car Starts Smoking From the Hood | PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair
April 25, 2025
PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair in River, NJ, explains what to do if smoke comes from under your hood and what it could mean for your engine.
What’s the Best Way to Remove Bug Splatter From My Car? | PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair
March 28, 2025
PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair in Toms River, NJ, explains the best way to remove bug splatter from your car. Protect your paint with these effective cleaning tips.
How Do I Know If My Catalytic Converter Needs Replacement? | PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair
February 28, 2025
PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair in Toms River, NJ, explains how to know if your catalytic converter needs replacement. Learn the warning signs and when to seek repairs.
What Are the Warning Signs of a Bad Alternator? | PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair
January 31, 2025
PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair in Toms River, NJ, outlines the warning signs of a bad alternator. Learn when to seek professional help for your vehicle.
How to Defrost Your Windshield Quickly and Safely | PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair
December 20, 2024
Learn the best methods to defrost your windshield quickly and safely, ensuring clear visibility and a smooth start to your drive on cold mornings.
The Importance of Pre-Holiday Winter Car Checks | PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair
November 28, 2024
PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair emphasizes the importance of pre-holiday winter car checks. Ensure your vehicle is safe and ready for winter travel.
Can I Drive with the Check Engine Light On? | PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair
October 30, 2024
PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair explains if it's safe to drive with the check engine light on. Learn about the risks and necessary actions to take.
Halloween Car Care Tips: Avoid a Frightening Breakdown | PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair
September 27, 2024
PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair shares Halloween car care tips to avoid a frightening breakdown. Learn how to keep your car running smoothly this spooky season.
How Can I Avoid Hitting Animals While Driving? | PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair
August 26, 2024
PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair offers tips to prevent animal collisions. Drive defensively, be aware of wildlife habitats, and ensure your headlights are in good condition.
What Happens to Your Old Oil After an Oil Change? | PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair
July 25, 2024
Don't toss that used oil! PRO-CAT Auto Care & Repair explains how used oil is recycled and reused, protecting the environment. Learn how your oil change helps!
More Posts